File #2753: "2019_Book_TheEvolvingInternationalProced.pdf"
Text
1|Contents|5
1|Abbreviations|8
1|Chapter 1: Preliminary Remarks|10
2|1.1 The Individual’s Procedural Handicap|10
2|1.2 A Matter of International Subjectivity|15
2|1.3 Determining International Procedural Capacity|21
3|1.3.1 Conventional Commitment|23
3|1.3.2 Procedural Embedding|25
3|1.3.3 Substance of Relief|26
2|1.4 Object of Study|27
3|1.4.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|30
3|1.4.2 Diplomatic Protection|33
3|1.4.3 Adhesion Procedure|35
2|1.5 Outline of Study|38
2|References|39
1|Chapter 2: Conventional Commitment|43
2|2.1 Accession|43
3|2.1.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|44
3|2.1.2 Diplomatic Protection|48
3|2.1.3 Adhesion Procedure|54
3|2.1.4 Conclusion|58
2|2.2 Reservations|60
3|2.2.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|61
3|2.2.2 Diplomatic Protection|67
3|2.2.3 Adhesion Procedure|71
3|2.2.4 Conclusion|74
2|2.3 Withdrawal|76
3|2.3.1 Traditional Human Rights Mechanisms|78
3|2.3.2 Diplomatic Protection|82
3|2.3.3 Adhesion Procedure|85
3|2.3.4 Conclusion|89
2|2.4 Conclusion|90
2|References|93
1|Chapter 3: Procedural Embedding|97
2|3.1 The Power to Initiate Proceedings|97
3|3.1.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|99
4|3.1.1.1 Restrictions Related to the Complainant|100
4|3.1.1.2 Restrictions Related to the Infringement of Rights|105
3|3.1.2 Diplomatic Protection|107
4|3.1.2.1 Limits to the Exercise of Diplomatic Protection|108
4|3.1.2.2 Restrictions to the State’s Discretion|111
3|3.1.3 Adhesion Procedure|114
4|3.1.3.1 Triggering Criminal Proceedings|116
4|3.1.3.2 Instigating the Reparation Stage|119
3|3.1.4 Conclusion|121
2|3.2 Local Remedies Rule|122
3|3.2.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|124
3|3.2.2 Diplomatic Protection|130
3|3.2.3 Adhesion Procedure|134
3|3.2.4 Conclusion|141
2|3.3 Parallel International Proceedings|142
3|3.3.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|143
3|3.3.2 Diplomatic Protection|147
3|3.3.3 Adhesion Procedure|150
3|3.3.4 Conclusion|153
2|3.4 Conclusion|154
2|References|157
1|Chapter 4: Substance of Relief|162
2|4.1 Remedial Options|162
3|4.1.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|164
4|4.1.1.1 Interim Measures of Relief|164
4|4.1.1.2 Final Measures of Relief|168
3|4.1.2 Diplomatic Protection|173
4|4.1.2.1 Interim Measures of Relief|173
4|4.1.2.2 Final Measures of Relief|179
3|4.1.3 Adhesive Procedure|183
4|4.1.3.1 Interim Measures of Relief|183
4|4.1.3.2 Final Measures of Relief|188
3|4.1.4 Conclusion|194
2|4.2 The Legal Nature of Remedial Awards|195
3|4.2.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|197
4|4.2.1.1 Interim Measures of Relief|197
4|4.2.1.2 Final Measures of Relief|203
3|4.2.2 Diplomatic Protection|207
4|4.2.2.1 Interim Measures of Relief|207
4|4.2.2.2 Final Measures of Relief|211
3|4.2.3 Adhesive Procedure|213
4|4.2.3.1 Interim Measures of Relief|213
4|4.2.3.2 Final Measures of Relief|217
3|4.2.4 Conclusion|218
2|4.3 Enforcement of Remedial Awards|220
3|4.3.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|222
4|4.3.1.1 Interim Measures of Relief|222
4|4.3.1.2 Final Measures of Relief|226
3|4.3.2 Diplomatic Protection|232
4|4.3.2.1 Interim Measures of Relief|232
4|4.3.2.2 Final Measures of Relief|236
3|4.3.3 Adhesive Procedure|241
4|4.3.3.1 Interim Measures of Relief|242
4|4.3.3.2 Final Measures of Relief|247
3|4.3.4 Conclusion|253
2|4.4 Conclusion|255
2|References|258
1|Chapter 5: Observations and Final Remarks|264
2|5.1 The Individual in International Adjudication|264
3|5.1.1 The UN Individual Complaint Procedure Before the UN Committees|264
3|5.1.2 Diplomatic Protection Before the ICJ|267
3|5.1.3 Adhesion Procedure Before the ICC|270
2|5.2 The International Procedural Capacity of the Individual|273
3|5.2.1 Common Patterns of Evolving Procedural Strength|274
3|5.2.2 The Unsuitability of a Vertical Comparison|276
3|5.2.3 Limits and Prospects|277
2|5.3 A Step Towards Subjectivity|278
3|5.3.1 The Increasing Importance of International Judicial Bodies: Active Adjudication|279
3|5.3.2 The Decreasing Importance of State Sovereignty: Activist Adjudication|283
3|5.3.3 The Less Dependent Individual|286
2|References|287
1|Table of Cases|289
1|Table of Other Documents|303
1|Index|312
1|Abbreviations|8
1|Chapter 1: Preliminary Remarks|10
2|1.1 The Individual’s Procedural Handicap|10
2|1.2 A Matter of International Subjectivity|15
2|1.3 Determining International Procedural Capacity|21
3|1.3.1 Conventional Commitment|23
3|1.3.2 Procedural Embedding|25
3|1.3.3 Substance of Relief|26
2|1.4 Object of Study|27
3|1.4.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|30
3|1.4.2 Diplomatic Protection|33
3|1.4.3 Adhesion Procedure|35
2|1.5 Outline of Study|38
2|References|39
1|Chapter 2: Conventional Commitment|43
2|2.1 Accession|43
3|2.1.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|44
3|2.1.2 Diplomatic Protection|48
3|2.1.3 Adhesion Procedure|54
3|2.1.4 Conclusion|58
2|2.2 Reservations|60
3|2.2.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|61
3|2.2.2 Diplomatic Protection|67
3|2.2.3 Adhesion Procedure|71
3|2.2.4 Conclusion|74
2|2.3 Withdrawal|76
3|2.3.1 Traditional Human Rights Mechanisms|78
3|2.3.2 Diplomatic Protection|82
3|2.3.3 Adhesion Procedure|85
3|2.3.4 Conclusion|89
2|2.4 Conclusion|90
2|References|93
1|Chapter 3: Procedural Embedding|97
2|3.1 The Power to Initiate Proceedings|97
3|3.1.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|99
4|3.1.1.1 Restrictions Related to the Complainant|100
4|3.1.1.2 Restrictions Related to the Infringement of Rights|105
3|3.1.2 Diplomatic Protection|107
4|3.1.2.1 Limits to the Exercise of Diplomatic Protection|108
4|3.1.2.2 Restrictions to the State’s Discretion|111
3|3.1.3 Adhesion Procedure|114
4|3.1.3.1 Triggering Criminal Proceedings|116
4|3.1.3.2 Instigating the Reparation Stage|119
3|3.1.4 Conclusion|121
2|3.2 Local Remedies Rule|122
3|3.2.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|124
3|3.2.2 Diplomatic Protection|130
3|3.2.3 Adhesion Procedure|134
3|3.2.4 Conclusion|141
2|3.3 Parallel International Proceedings|142
3|3.3.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|143
3|3.3.2 Diplomatic Protection|147
3|3.3.3 Adhesion Procedure|150
3|3.3.4 Conclusion|153
2|3.4 Conclusion|154
2|References|157
1|Chapter 4: Substance of Relief|162
2|4.1 Remedial Options|162
3|4.1.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|164
4|4.1.1.1 Interim Measures of Relief|164
4|4.1.1.2 Final Measures of Relief|168
3|4.1.2 Diplomatic Protection|173
4|4.1.2.1 Interim Measures of Relief|173
4|4.1.2.2 Final Measures of Relief|179
3|4.1.3 Adhesive Procedure|183
4|4.1.3.1 Interim Measures of Relief|183
4|4.1.3.2 Final Measures of Relief|188
3|4.1.4 Conclusion|194
2|4.2 The Legal Nature of Remedial Awards|195
3|4.2.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|197
4|4.2.1.1 Interim Measures of Relief|197
4|4.2.1.2 Final Measures of Relief|203
3|4.2.2 Diplomatic Protection|207
4|4.2.2.1 Interim Measures of Relief|207
4|4.2.2.2 Final Measures of Relief|211
3|4.2.3 Adhesive Procedure|213
4|4.2.3.1 Interim Measures of Relief|213
4|4.2.3.2 Final Measures of Relief|217
3|4.2.4 Conclusion|218
2|4.3 Enforcement of Remedial Awards|220
3|4.3.1 UN Individual Complaint Procedure|222
4|4.3.1.1 Interim Measures of Relief|222
4|4.3.1.2 Final Measures of Relief|226
3|4.3.2 Diplomatic Protection|232
4|4.3.2.1 Interim Measures of Relief|232
4|4.3.2.2 Final Measures of Relief|236
3|4.3.3 Adhesive Procedure|241
4|4.3.3.1 Interim Measures of Relief|242
4|4.3.3.2 Final Measures of Relief|247
3|4.3.4 Conclusion|253
2|4.4 Conclusion|255
2|References|258
1|Chapter 5: Observations and Final Remarks|264
2|5.1 The Individual in International Adjudication|264
3|5.1.1 The UN Individual Complaint Procedure Before the UN Committees|264
3|5.1.2 Diplomatic Protection Before the ICJ|267
3|5.1.3 Adhesion Procedure Before the ICC|270
2|5.2 The International Procedural Capacity of the Individual|273
3|5.2.1 Common Patterns of Evolving Procedural Strength|274
3|5.2.2 The Unsuitability of a Vertical Comparison|276
3|5.2.3 Limits and Prospects|277
2|5.3 A Step Towards Subjectivity|278
3|5.3.1 The Increasing Importance of International Judicial Bodies: Active Adjudication|279
3|5.3.2 The Decreasing Importance of State Sovereignty: Activist Adjudication|283
3|5.3.3 The Less Dependent Individual|286
2|References|287
1|Table of Cases|289
1|Table of Other Documents|303
1|Index|312